Both are taken in the same stadium - at the same end of that stadium - though you wouldn't know that to look at the videos.
Both go low to the goalkeeper's right but the lighting, the grass, the ball, the goalkeeper's dive, the goalposts and the goalnets themselves are all different.
Everything's different. In the 13 years separating these two penatlies, everything had changed.
But in the simple aesthetic of the ball hitting the net, the two penalties are the same.